Reimbursement
Medicare NCDs vs LCDs: how coverage decisions for devices are made
NCD vs LCD: how Medicare national coverage determinations and local coverage determinations differ, who writes them, and how each process and timeline works.
By the All In MedTech editorial team · Published November 19, 2026 · 6 min read
A National Coverage Determination (NCD) is a decision by CMS on whether Medicare covers an item or service anywhere in the country. A Local Coverage Determination (LCD) is the same kind of decision made by a regional Medicare Administrative Contractor (MAC) for its own jurisdiction. NCDs come first: contractors must follow them, and an LCD can only fill in where no NCD applies or where the NCD leaves room.
Both are coverage decisions, which means they decide whether Medicare pays at all, and for which patients. They do not set the payment amount. This post explains who makes each, how the processes and timelines work, and how to find the documents for a device.
The legal basis
Medicare covers items and services that are "reasonable and necessary for the diagnosis or treatment of illness or injury," under section 1862(a)(1)(A) of the Social Security Act. NCDs and LCDs are the two written ways Medicare applies that test to a specific technology.
- NCDs are defined in section 1869(f)(1)(B) of the Act and made by CMS's Coverage and Analysis Group. The process rules, including the timelines, are in section 1862(l).
- LCDs are defined in section 1869(f)(2)(B) as a contractor's decision on whether an item or service is covered on a contractor-wide basis. The process is set out in chapter 13 of the Medicare Program Integrity Manual.
Many services have neither. In that case the MAC decides individual claims under the same reasonable and necessary standard.
NCD vs LCD at a glance
| National Coverage Determination | Local Coverage Determination | |
|---|---|---|
| Made by | CMS | A Medicare Administrative Contractor |
| Applies in | The whole country | The contractor's jurisdiction |
| Binding on | All MACs, appeals adjudicators and Medicare Advantage plans | Claims processed by that contractor |
| Started by | A formal request or CMS's own initiative | A request or the contractor's own initiative |
| Proposed decision | Posted within 6 or 9 months of opening | Posted as a proposed LCD |
| Public comment | 30 days | At least 45 calendar days |
| Before it takes effect | Final decision within 60 days of comment closing | Notice period of at least 45 calendar days |
| Companion documents | National coverage analysis and decision memo | Billing and coding articles, response to comments article |
How an NCD is made
CMS describes the process on its coverage determination process page. In outline:
- Request. Anyone can ask CMS to open or reconsider an NCD, usually a manufacturer, medical society or clinician group. CMS's request page lists what a complete request needs. CMS can also open a review itself.
- Opening. When CMS accepts a request, it opens a national coverage analysis (NCA) and posts a tracking sheet with an initial 30-day comment period.
- Evidence review. CMS reviews the published evidence. It may commission an outside technology assessment or ask the Medicare Evidence Development & Coverage Advisory Committee (MEDCAC) for advice.
- Proposed decision memo. Posted for 30 days of public comment.
- Final decision memo. Responds to the comments and sets the coverage policy. The NCD is then added to the NCD manual and implemented through instructions to contractors.
The statutory clock
Section 1862(l) sets the timeline, and CMS restates it on its process page:
- The proposed decision is due within 6 months of opening if CMS uses no outside technology assessment or MEDCAC review, or within 9 months if it does.
- Public comment on the proposed decision runs 30 days.
- The final decision is due no later than 60 days after the comment period ends.
So a typical NCA runs roughly 9 to 12 months from opening to final decision.
Coverage with evidence development
An NCD can cover a technology only when the patient is enrolled in an approved study or registry. This is called coverage with evidence development (CED). It lets Medicare pay while more evidence is gathered, and it is common for newer implantable devices. CMS lists approved CED studies on its coverage pages.
Reconsideration and removal
An NCD can be reconsidered at the request of anyone who brings new evidence. Since a 2013 Federal Register notice, CMS also has an expedited process to remove NCDs that are more than 10 years past their last review, which hands the topic back to local contractors.
How an LCD is made
MACs handle Medicare claims for defined regions. CMS lists 12 A/B MACs and 4 durable medical equipment MACs. Each can write LCDs for its jurisdiction. Chapter 13 of the Program Integrity Manual sets the process.
- Request or contractor initiative. Anyone can request a new LCD or a reconsideration, with supporting evidence. Under the manual, the MAC reviews a request within 60 calendar days to decide whether it is complete.
- Proposed LCD. The MAC publishes the draft in the Medicare Coverage Database with a summary sheet.
- Public comment. At least 45 calendar days.
- Open meeting. The MAC holds a public meeting on the proposal where stakeholders can present.
- Contractor Advisory Committee (CAC). When used, clinicians and beneficiary representatives advise the MAC. The CAC is advisory only.
- Final LCD and response to comments. The MAC publishes the final LCD with a response to comments article.
- Notice period. At least 45 calendar days before the LCD takes effect. The 21st Century Cures Act wrote this notice period, and the publication of the evidence and rationale behind the decision, into section 1862(l)(5)(D).
The manual also says MACs should finalize or retire a proposed LCD within a year of publishing it.
Jurisdictions often work together
Several MACs may adopt the same LCD, either because the policy was developed jointly or because one contractor's LCD was copied by others. This is why the same policy can appear several times in the database under different document numbers.
What sits around an LCD: articles
LCDs often come with billing and coding articles. Articles do not make coverage decisions. They list the codes that apply, the diagnosis codes that support medical necessity, and billing instructions. For many device questions the article is where the practical detail sits.
Challenging a decision
The two types also differ in how they can be challenged. An aggrieved beneficiary can challenge an LCD or an NCD through the process in 42 CFR Part 426, which goes before an administrative law judge for LCDs and the Departmental Appeals Board for NCDs. Manufacturers and other stakeholders usually use the reconsideration routes instead.
Which one should a device company focus on
It depends on the technology.
- A national decision gives certainty across the country but takes longer, carries more evidence demands and can be restrictive. Companies often seek one when MACs are reluctant to act or when local policies conflict.
- Local coverage can come faster and can be tested in one region, but it creates a patchwork, and a single MAC's non-coverage LCD can block an area.
- Some technologies never need either. If an existing code and payment cover the service and MACs pay claims, written policy may not be required.
For certain Breakthrough devices, CMS's TCET pathway offers a faster route to a national decision. See TCET explained. For how coverage fits with coding and payment, see how device reimbursement works.
Finding NCDs and LCDs for a device
All NCDs, national coverage analyses, LCDs, proposed LCDs and articles are in CMS's Medicare Coverage Database. You can search by keyword, document type, contractor and state.
When you read a coverage document, check:
- Status and dates: proposed, final, future effective or retired.
- Indications and limitations: which patients and settings are covered and which are not.
- Evidence requirements: for example study enrollment under CED, or specific documentation.
- Which contractors and states it applies to, for LCDs.
- The linked articles, for codes and billing instructions.
Coverage policy changes often, so always check the current version in the database before relying on it.
Frequently asked questions
- What is the difference between an NCD and an LCD?
- An NCD is a national Medicare coverage decision made by CMS that applies everywhere, while an LCD is made by a regional Medicare Administrative Contractor and applies only in its jurisdiction.
- Which takes priority, an NCD or an LCD?
- The NCD. Contractors must follow NCDs, and an LCD cannot conflict with one, though an LCD can add detail where the NCD leaves room.
- How long does an NCD take?
- By statute CMS must post a proposed decision within 6 months of opening a review, or 9 months if it uses an outside technology assessment or its advisory committee, then allow 30 days of comment and issue a final decision within 60 days after comment closes.
- How long is the LCD comment period?
- The Program Integrity Manual requires at least 45 calendar days of public comment on a proposed LCD, and at least 45 calendar days of notice before a final LCD takes effect.
For information only, not medical, legal or investment advice. Facts about FDA, CMS and SEC rules are current as of the publication date; check the linked official source for changes.